In the midst of this increasingly competitive war for talent, you’re doing well if you just have people in seats. It means you’re filling positions, retaining the team, and keeping absenteeism to a minimum. No worries to be had, right?
Old-fashioned HR managers may use attendance as the metric for measuring success, but observant people and culture pros know team members can be at work without being fully present. As it turns out, efforts to clamp down on absenteeism may have led to a worse situation at work—rampant presenteeism.
What is presenteeism?
Presenteeism occurs when ongoing physical or mental conditions prevent employees from being fully productive at work. Examples of ailments that can affect your people include asthma, arthritis, migraines, allergies, depression, diabetes, and anxiety; the list of culprits is long and varied, which means your team could be more affected than you realize.
Presenteeism is not a matter of shirking one’s responsibilities or disengagement with work. “We’re talking about people hanging in there when they get sick and trying to figure out ways to carry on despite their symptoms,” explains Debra Lerner of Tufts University School of Medicine in a Harvard Business Review article. In cases of presenteeism, team members want to give their best efforts but cannot deliver because of health issues or personal problems. Pain, whether physical, mental, or emotional, has a great influence, disrupting concentration and increasing fatigue.
It’s costing you
Productivity loss as a result of presenteeism is three times greater than losses caused by absenteeism and costs US businesses almost 230 billion dollars each year. That’s a pretty expensive problem to have.
Presenteeism can result in heavy costs for your teams as well. Colleagues might feel pressured to pick up the slack for inefficient team members, thus adding more to their own plate just so the work gets done. Feeling stressed and strained, helpful teammates may find they can no longer be as productive at work. When this becomes a pattern, that will breed resentment if unchecked and create a vicious circle.
A new problem?
Research into presenteeism began circa 2000, but the issue has been around a lot longer than that. According to Norman Clemens of the American Psychiatric Association, presenteeism is just “a new catchword for an old problem,” and one that’s garnered increasing attention as of late.
Due to strategic directions that were taken in the past, presenteeism is becoming more and more pervasive. Attempts to cut down on absenteeism led some companies to adopt way too restrictive time off policies. How many times have you heard someone say, mid-sneeze, “It’s just a cold,” or complain of a persistent neck crick while at the office? As the number of allotted sick days decreases, it’s common to see people saving them for when they’re ‘really’ needed—like flu season, or when their own child is ill.
Predictors of presenteeism
There are a number of contributing factors that dissuade employees from taking time off—from company culture cues to personal reasons—and increase the likelihood of presenteeism in your workplace.
- Less obvious workplace cues can make taking time off seem taboo to your workforce. Do managers come into the office when they have the flu? Are tasks pushed back or reassigned when someone is sick, or are they expected to catch up once they’re feeling better? Does taking a personal day guarantee a guilt trip the moment an individual returns back to the office? Team members take notice of these little things and come to the conclusion that your workplace culture is restrictive and unsupportive of time off policies. As a result, they may think twice before calling in sick again.
- Presenteeism is more rampant in organizations that have recently experienced company downsizing or restructuring. Worried about their jobs, team members will tough it out in the hopes of proving their worth and value to their management and leadership.
- Employees with lower hourly wages or who work only on a casual/part-time basis are more prone to presenteeism. Team members with lower income would be unable to make ends meet on a smaller paycheque and therefore cannot risk missing days away from work. Because of their financial need, these workers come into work even when they should take a sick day.
- Parenthood is another contributing factor to presenteeism. The rise of the dual-income household means that these days, there’s no one home to care for children who are unwell. As a result, many parents conserve sick days so that they can stay home when their kids are under the weather. Of course, that means these parents are back at work just as they’re getting sick, having caught the same bug their child is now getting over.
What can you do to prevent presenteeism?
First things first: tell your team members that you want them to be able to give their best efforts when they’re at work. If they’re unable to perform at their best, they should stay home when they’re sick and take the occasional mental health day. The goal is to clearly communicate what’s acceptable and what isn’t: for example, your company might allow mental health days, but if requested in the middle of a major project, there may need to be a discussion first. Do away with unspoken rules in favour of clear, articulated guidelines that apply to everyone.
Next, revisit your current time off policies. An employee engagement survey can help you gauge how well your current one is working. That said, even offering just a few more sick days each year can send a powerful message to your team, plus go a long way toward building your employer brand. Do you want to be the company that offers the bare minimum, or one that goes above and beyond what’s typically offered?
Introducing flextime, telecommuting and other remote work options will provide alternative options to parents who need to stay home with a sick kid, or to people who can’t afford to miss a day of work. It will also alleviate the anxiety team members might feel about missing deadlines while away.
Design a comprehensive group benefits plan that makes mental health and mental illness a priority. Generally speaking, physical health conditions result in more absenteeism. It’s less visible conditions, like anxiety or depression, that drive up presenteeism.
You can help your team members to manage their mental health by ensuring that your group benefits cover any medications they may need, as well as counselling and support services. Make sure to consider how paramedicals, like massage therapy or acupuncture, might alleviate stress and help your team members to be fully present at work.
Over to you
What does it mean to show up at work? Is it the number of people in their seats? Clocking in? Replying to emails as soon as they arrive in your inbox? It’s past time we stopped using examples like these as the measures of success. Presenteeism is a far greater concern for the modern people and culture pro—and unfortunately, it’s a lot more challenging to monitor. To track presenteeism, you need to be in tune with your team and be able to recognize when they’re struggling. More than that, your company must be willing to provide the tools and the time necessary for someone to recover, reset, and return to optimal productivity. As the research shows, it’s worth it—both for the business and for your people.